Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Tue Feb 12, 2019 8:00 am  

But with injury surely it's not just the games he has already missed, but the long term prognosis on those injuries and how his body in general will stand up to such a demanding position, and our medical team would have taken a view on this. He may have started well at HKR but if the long term view was that his body wouldn't stand up to it then the right decision had to be to let him go.

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Tue Feb 12, 2019 9:19 am  

HRS Rhino wrote:

But with injury surely it's not just the games he has already missed, but the long term prognosis on those injuries and how his body in general will stand up to such a demanding position, and our medical team would have taken a view on this. He may have started well at HKR but if the long term view was that his body wouldn't stand up to it then the right decision had to be to let him go.

I think this is right, the medical and conditioning staff at the club have a very good idea of where each player is at. The club will also factor in general attitude, how the player trains, etc.
Without being inside the camp it's very hard to know.
No player is going to want to believe their body is knackered if their livelihood depends on it, so a difference of opinion is natural.

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Sun Feb 17, 2019 6:35 pm  

Two tries and mom today

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Sun Feb 17, 2019 6:50 pm  

fun time frankie wrote:

Two tries and mom today

Good for him, some people really need to let it go, he’s not a Rhinos player anymore

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:56 pm  

Highlighting the sheer stupidity of letting our best prop go at a time we were, and still remain, weak of props is still very worthy of discussion.

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Sun Feb 17, 2019 10:06 pm  

The Ghost of '99 wrote:

Highlighting the sheer stupidity of letting our best prop go at a time we were, and still remain, weak of props is still very worthy of discussion.

3 decent games doesnt highlight zip we've moved on & the rebuild continues.

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Mon Feb 18, 2019 7:03 am  

The Ghost of '99 wrote:

Highlighting the sheer stupidity of letting our best prop go at a time we were, and still remain, weak of props is still very worthy of discussion.

Indeed. He's on fire at the moment for KR and its worthy of discussion. I think salary cap and overseas player limits have played a part in letting him go as well as his injury record but it looks at present like a mistake but let's judge at season end

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Mon Feb 18, 2019 2:27 pm  

there are a handful of players in my time that in my opinion letting go was a massive mistake. Paul medley, Bobbie Goulding, Roy Powell (replacing him with mick Worrall) and Jimmy lowes probably the worst of all.
Mitch Garbut is not one of them and i dont think he will prove to be either. he may have a stormer and win man of match when he plays us, see Rob Roberts after he went to Hull, see Brendan Hill every time he played Leeds for about 2 years before disappearing into the lower divisions. we could have a thread about players we have let go and the mixed fortunes, but we have let player go much better than garbutt with little regrets except those i mentioned, who all bit us on the booty may many times for different reasons.

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Mon Feb 18, 2019 4:51 pm  

Didn’t Garbutt going mean that we could get Merrin?

I know whi I would rather have

Re: OUT 2019 | Mitch Garbutt - Hull KR : Mon Feb 18, 2019 6:11 pm  

No it did not and now we are looking at props no where near the standard of Garbutt