Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:23 pm  

Hardaker 8 A good all round performance, getting better every week
Davies 5 Couldnt make any impact, was pushed backwards too much
Gildart 4 A filthy performance in the first half. Awful defence. Worst performance ive ever seen from him. A bit better second half
Sarginson 7 As always tried his heart out and a couple of dangerous runs
Marshall 7 Safe, great effort for his try
Williams 7 Tried very hard and some nice touches but needs more options from his runners
Tommy 6 Some awful defence as per Gildart but he actually looked quite good in attack
Flower 7 Great opening but spoiled it with his PTB mistake
Powell 6 Great defence as always, no threat in attack. We need more from our 9.
Clubb 5 No impact at all, looks slow and ineffective
Farrell 5 Ineffective, tried hard but looks lost and awkward on the right
Greenwood 8 Looked very threatening, very good all round
O'Loughlin 8 Great performance as always.

Isa 4 I dont know how much this guy is on but if its more than peanuts we need to get rid. Tries hard but offers nothing
Navarette 5 Not sure why but he has lost what he gained last season. Needs more aggression.
Hamlin 6 Tried hard with little impact
Bullock 7 Some strong runs but fades too quickly

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:35 pm  

For once I can’t argue with any of that. I agree about ISA, how he gets picked is beyond me, he offers absolutely nothing in attack or defence. We do need some size in our pack and a big centre to boot. Greenwood was superb tonight along with O’Loughlin, not sure how Williams got MOM other than his pass to Marshall he was rabbits in headlights.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:39 pm  

hatty wrote:

For once I can’t argue with any of that. I agree about ISA, how he gets picked is beyond me, he offers absolutely nothing in attack or defence. We do need some size in our pack and a big centre to boot. Greenwood was superb tonight along with O’Loughlin, not sure how Williams got MOM other than his pass to Marshall he was rabbits in headlights.

Is it Williams or is it our attacking shape outside him? He deffo wasnt MOM.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:48 pm  

A frustrating night. I’ll be honest, I thought to only lose by 12 before the game would’ve meant we’d played well and we did anything but. We were very poor in the first half and only slightly better in the second half. Those defensive efforts for their first two try’s (and all 4 in truth) were pretty diabolical and I’d have been disappointed to concede them against London.

A missed opportunity.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:48 pm  

The_Enforcer wrote:

Is it Williams or is it our attacking shape outside him? He deffo wasnt MOM.

Possibly a bit of both, it’s probably wrong for me to criticise him entirely as he will be working to a game plan. Whatever plan it is though it doesn’t suit his style of play, I think we may see a better Williams when Sammut returns. Greenwood or lockers MOM for me

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:53 pm  

NickyKiss wrote:

A frustrating night. I’ll be honest, I thought to only lose by 12 before the game would’ve meant we’d played well and we did anything but. We were very poor in the first half and only slightly better in the second half. Those defensive efforts for their first two try’s (and all 4 in truth) were pretty diabolical and I’d have been disappointed to concede them against London.

A missed opportunity.

Strange thing is it was Gildart, Tommy and Farrell, 3 normally very good defenders who were to blame.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:56 pm  

The_Enforcer wrote:

Strange thing is it was Gildart, Tommy and Farrell, 3 normally very good defenders who were to blame.

Just a bad day at the office, the Morris try where he was “held up” over the line was exactly that “held up” his movement had stop and u can see hicks put his whistle to his mouth to signal that

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 9:58 pm  

What has to happen for people to stop bigging up Hardaker?

I’m sure he will improve but thus far for me he has been bang average at best.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 10:05 pm  

jonh wrote:

What has to happen for people to stop bigging up Hardaker?

I’m sure he will improve but thus far for me he has been bang average at best.

Average? Apart from the knock on after he took the high bomb he was flawless. He is finding his dancing feet again and starting to get a little more involved.

Re: Player ratings WCC : Sun Feb 17, 2019 10:08 pm  

hatty wrote:

Just a bad day at the office, the Morris try where he was “held up” over the line was exactly that “held up” his movement had stop and u can see hicks put his whistle to his mouth to signal that

In all fairness i thought that but looking on the replay i think he was just ok by the skin of his teeth. A fraction of a fraction of a second more i think it would of been held