Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 8:24 am  

Rocky Bobby wrote:

Amused by Danny McGuire's histrionics about foul play, waving his elbow at anyone who would look at it. Perhaps thats what he was doing in the second half when he gave a tackled Goodwin a facial on the floor with his forearm...

Was McGuire actually gesturing that though? The way I saw it was that McGuire was gesturing to his team mates to pull into position so he could take advantage of Warrington’s defence being in disarray.

Once he realises the ball has been lost he seems to protest for a steal, which is standard player response when their own team loses possession.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 9:24 am  

I was watching from the North Stand, almost in line but obviously some yards back and without the benefit of replay. My first reaction was that the tackle was not complete but there was a suspicion that Austin's forearm hay have ended up above the shoulder. Had Tompkins not stayed down / lost the ball it would have been play on as it wasn't clear.

The replay from the South Stand, from my point of view, confirms that the tackle was incomplete but you cannot see any contact. Clearly the player was concussed so he has presumably received a blow to the head either from direct contact with Austin or with the ground. The RL are rightly keen to protect players from head injury so chances are that Austin will be sitting out the next few.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 9:37 am  

It'll also be interesting to see how the disciplinary panel view the head high tackle on Cooper as he goes over for his try.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 9:43 am  

silver2 wrote:

It'll also be interesting to see how the disciplinary panel view the head high tackle on Cooper as he goes over for his try.

And somebody having a go at Charnley's knee in front of the south stand.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 11:13 am  

nothing in it as far as I can see. Tomkins has just got his head in the wrong position .... no knees no elbows. unless Austin has punched him in the head I cant see any foul play.....

nothing in it as far as I can see. Tomkins has just got his head in the wrong position .... no knees no elbows. unless Austin has punched him in the head I cant see any foul play.....

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 11:42 am  

We've got footage from the northstand

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 11:45 am  

the flying biscuit wrote: nothing in it as far as I can see. Tomkins has just got his head in the wrong position .... no knees no elbows. unless Austin has punched him in the head I cant see any foul play..... All joking aside, I watched the video, the more I watched it, the less I thought there was in it, his knees come down at his hips/midriff. His left arm goes over the body, the only thing you cant see is the right hand, but you would expect him to swing his arm or raise his elbow in order to connect so hard that it fractures a skull. In fact I then started watching it again in case I'd missed ratch do something. But no.

the flying biscuit wrote: nothing in it as far as I can see. Tomkins has just got his head in the wrong position .... no knees no elbows. unless Austin has punched him in the head I cant see any foul play..... All joking aside, I watched the video, the more I watched it, the less I thought there was in it, his knees come down at his hips/midriff. His left arm goes over the body, the only thing you cant see is the right hand, but you would expect him to swing his arm or raise his elbow in order to connect so hard that it fractures a skull. In fact I then started watching it again in case I'd missed ratch do something. But no.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 11:57 am  

Tomkins is out of hospital, it was concussion and he could be okay next week as its outside the concussion window! Much a do about nothing from everything I have seen. This was just unfortunate, I think it was the ground personally but again there may be replays that bring new evidence to light that we haven't seen.

I'm glad tomkins is OK, he may have grub tendencies but he's been a good player over the years. I can't see any reason for there to be a ban for this incident after a sin binning, in fact the sin bin looks harsh from what I've seen.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 12:04 pm  

That photograph would appear rule out knees, elbows to head and whether the tackle was complete. EXHIBIT1 for the defence I think.

Re: Today’s game v HKR. : Mon Feb 11, 2019 1:45 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

That photograph would appear rule out knees, elbows to head and whether the tackle was complete. EXHIBIT1 for the defence I think.

But what head, shoulders and toes? All together now...