Re: 1-13 at the DW : Thu Sep 12, 2019 9:56 pm  

Radlinski over Tomkins for me because Radlinski was easily the better defender and far safer under the high ball. Could Sam Tomkins have come up with that performance to win us the challenge cup at Murrayfied? No chance. People also forget Radlinski was a very good attacker. He topped the charts with 30 tries in 2001. Only one player I want back there at FB. Obviously Tomkins was unplayable on his day, he clearly belongs in the team so I've put him in the halves.

Re: 1-13 at the DW : Thu Sep 12, 2019 10:48 pm  

Grimmy wrote:

Radlinski over Tomkins for me because Radlinski was easily the better defender and far safer under the high ball. Could Sam Tomkins have come up with that performance to win us the challenge cup at Murrayfied? No chance. People also forget Radlinski was a very good attacker. He topped the charts with 30 tries in 2001. Only one player I want back there at FB. Obviously Tomkins was unplayable on his day, he clearly belongs in the team so I've put him in the halves.

But are you picking him on just performances or is he actually your favourite Wigan full back in the past 20 years, Tomkins only belongs in the team IF he is your favourite player in the position you chose him in, It's a shame that a huge number of fans will be picking on a performance basis rather than what the original article wanted

[DaveO]

Re: 1-13 at the DW : Thu Sep 12, 2019 11:16 pm  

When it went up on the big screen I can't say I disagreed with any of the choices.