Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Thu Jun 20, 2019 10:11 pm  

read my thread traffic I asked where the tj was stood.
I didnt need to see the replay to know what the in goal decision was.

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 12:10 am  

northernbloke wrote:

read my thread traffic I asked where the tj was stood.
I didnt need to see the replay to know what the in goal decision was.

Again what have you seen that leads you to say three people (TJ, in touch and ref) all thought it was no try? The post I commented on ends with you stating that, so how did you come to that conclusion?

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 5:41 am  

Well the ref thought it was no try because he didnt give it.
I asked where the tj was stood on the u tube vid that would have indicated that it was no try.
As for the in goal, I know for a fact he didnt think it was a try, i dont need to see the vid

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 7:12 am  

NB you didn't get 5th ref last night, is that because it was TV game?

Do you have a face for radio!

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 9:13 am  

They have a reserve ref and reserve tj
So I was in the crowd shouting

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 9:23 am  

northernbloke wrote:

Well the ref thought it was no try because he didnt give it.
I asked where the tj was stood on the u tube vid that would have indicated that it was no try.
As for the in goal, I know for a fact he didnt think it was a try, i dont need to see the vid

So do you actually know where tj stood ?

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 11:29 am  

northernbloke wrote:

Well the ref thought it was no try because he didnt give it.
I asked where the tj was stood on the u tube vid that would have indicated that it was no try.
As for the in goal, I know for a fact he didnt think it was a try, i dont need to see the vid

I give up, the ref can do no wrong. You keep asking for the video and then just happen to mention the in goal thought it was no try and you know for a fact (not doubting you may well know him or asked him BTW but it's like pulling teeth and I can't be asked anymore)

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 12:16 pm  

Ok I will put it simply. The origoonal poster stated that the only person who thought it was no try was the ref. He also stated the in goal judge even thought it was a try. I simply stated this was wrong, the in goal agreed with the ref, as for asking where the tj was stood on the video that would have shown what they thought! It's not difficult.
Watch any game with a try decision, where does tj go? Tj will as well as on comms will position himself in 1 of 3 positions. 1 is try other is not seen grounding but happy with everything else, last indicates he has seen something that could mean no try,

I never said and never have said the ref can do no wrong! In fact I constantly repeat just like players errors are made, it's part of the game.

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Fri Jun 21, 2019 1:36 pm  

northernbloke wrote:

Ok I will put it simply. The origoonal poster stated that the only person who thought it was no try was the ref. He also stated the in goal judge even thought it was a try. I simply stated this was wrong, the in goal agreed with the ref, as for asking where the tj was stood on the video that would have shown what they thought! It's not difficult.
Watch any game with a try decision, where does tj go? Tj will as well as on comms will position himself in 1 of 3 positions. 1 is try other is not seen grounding but happy with everything else, last indicates he has seen something that could mean no try,

I never said and never have said the ref can do no wrong! In fact I constantly repeat just like players errors are made, it's part of the game.

You acknowledged earlier on in the thread it was probably a mistake and thats the one and only time I've seen you acknowledge a specific rather than general point. Let's leave it at that.

Re: 4 or 5 More wins? : Sat Jun 22, 2019 10:48 pm  

At the risk of AGAIN trying to get this back on thread, after the last 3 weeks I really don't know what to expect in terms of London and the other strugglers results.
Key results other than ours this week will be the Hull Derby, Leeds v Catalan and Wakey v Huddersfield......FC/Catalan/Wakey wins and regardless of our result, we are a game closer to safety, but I can see Leeds beating the French who seem to have given up of late.....they were dire v FC. FC beating HKR is the most important....the longer they are adrift at the foot of the table, the more their confidence will drop.....that said, if we can beat Castleford, then I'd risk a tenner on us staying up!