Re: SL RD 28 | Salford Red Devils (H) : Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:48 pm  

The problem is the way the production line faltered for years in the middle. We’ve had it working much better again for a few years now, but it takes a long time to filter through.

Then again you’ll always have peaks and troughs of talent even with a good development system.

Re: SL RD 28 | Salford Red Devils (H) : Tue Sep 10, 2019 4:57 am  

KaeruJim wrote:

The problem is the way the production line faltered for years in the middle. We’ve had it working much better again for a few years now, but it takes a long time to filter through.

Then again you’ll always have peaks and troughs of talent even with a good development system.

I don't think it did falter though Jim.

For a decade we had a squad made up of a huge number of players that came through our academy who were top players, most of which became internationals. We were still producing good players they were just not good enough to get past the academy products we already had in the first team. It's very hard to have a sinfield and mags and then produce two players that are even better.

Re: SL RD 28 | Salford Red Devils (H) : Tue Sep 10, 2019 5:45 am  

I agree with that to an extent mate, but can you name me any real success stories since Sutcliffe and Handley until Oledzki/Smith/Walker?

For whatever reason there is a 3-4 (at least) gap from the Academy in terms of successful first team players produced.

Whether it’s just availability of talent, the quality of coaching at the time, the competition getting their act together and beating us to the talent or whatever... it’s about QED by looking at the first team quad now IMO.

Honesty it looks like the club failed to tool up the 3 years BEFORE the Goldens started to retire, and we did it after the wheels predictably fell off - and there we are three years out of four in relegation scraps as a result.

I may be being unkind because I know you don’t just snap your fingers and a Burrow and McGuire appear magically in your academy, but it doesn’t look well managed on the face.

Re: SL RD 28 | Salford Red Devils (H) : Tue Sep 10, 2019 7:28 am  

KaeruJim wrote:

I agree with that to an extent mate, but can you name me any real success stories since Sutcliffe and Handley until Oledzki/Smith/Walker?

For whatever reason there is a 3-4 (at least) gap from the Academy in terms of successful first team players produced.

Whether it’s just availability of talent, the quality of coaching at the time, the competition getting their act together and beating us to the talent or whatever... it’s about QED by looking at the first team quad now IMO.

Honesty it looks like the club failed to tool up the 3 years BEFORE the Goldens started to retire, and we did it after the wheels predictably fell off - and there we are three years out of four in relegation scraps as a result.

I may be being unkind because I know you don’t just snap your fingers and a Burrow and McGuire appear magically in your academy, but it doesn’t look well managed on the face.

I can see both sides of the argument here and I agree that we didn't have the required quality coming through ahead of time to fill the gaps left by the golden generation as we call them.

Did the club take their eye off the ball, was there a lack of genuine talent or did the talent take one look at the Leeds team and think they wouldn't get a game and choose a different club? Tbh we will never know.

What I would say though is that those that liken producing young players to a conveyor belt are a bit naive. It's not a constant process for any club in any sport. But having had some lean years we look like we have some great potential again. It's now making sure we integrate them in a sensible way.

Re: SL RD 28 | Salford Red Devils (H) : Tue Sep 10, 2019 7:48 am  

could be wrong but didnt it all go tits up when the 2 macdermotts start running it?