Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 3:44 pm  

Just wondering who everyone wants to see next year and the players that have had there chance and should go.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 4:25 pm  

Elima & Manuokafos are number 1 priority for me.

Then i'd sing Burgess, Donaldson (still got potential) Ainscough deserves a new deal (We need depth and have squad continiutity) Same reason i'd sign Hargreaves up.

I'd choose Manuokafoa over Sammut, but if Purtell has to retire then id give Sammut a new deal. But i really hope to see Purtell in a Bulls shirt again.

Im tempted by Walker. If he can stay fit towards the back end of the season, i'd give him a shot at a new contract. Undecided on Briggs or Jefferies. Sign Mcavoy as he is a youngster coming through

Elima - long term
Manuokafoa - long term
Burgess - Long term
Donaldson - 2 years
Hargreaves - 2 years
Shaun Ainscough - 2 years
Liam Mcavoy - 2 years
Jason Crookes - 2 years
Danny Addy - 2 years.

Undecided on Briggs, Jefferies & Walker.

I think its important we don't have too big a turn over, just make small changes to improve year on a year.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 5:39 pm  

Walker? are you being serious? he is constantly injured and when he does play barely makes an impact.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 5:55 pm  

Keep, BJ, Elima, Hargreaves, MnM, Donno, Addy, Burgess, Crookes, McAvoy, Pryce

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 6:31 pm  

So, how many times ARE you going to start the same thread?

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 6:35 pm  

Keep..
Jeffries
Elima
Hargreaves
Ainscough
Donaldson
Burgess
Sammut
Addy
Pryce

Gone for Sammut over Manase, simply because IMO the team played better when he and Jeffries were in the halves together...Gale would have to make a massive improvement for me to change my mind.

Pryce for me would get the extention only if Potter couldn't find a replacement on the wing, If Crookes doesn't go to Hull then let Pryce go.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 6:45 pm  

Bit hard to comment until we know what the future holds. If we survive but need to cut costs then maybe expect Sibbit, Walker, Ainy staying and some of the higher paid players like Elima etc leaving. If we are building a team to challenge for play offs then we need to be looking at better quality players than the above.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 6:59 pm  

I think there needs to be some serious consideration as to available replacements, depending on who we let go. It looks like Wigan have snapped up Matty Smith, so that's one option already gone if we are to let Sammut go.
I'm still not convinced that Kyle Briggs is good enough for SL, another season at Fev won't really have progressed his skill set any more than it was already.
But then if we keep Jarrod and let Nas go, we need another prop. So it all depends on who MP has lined up to replace whoever we get rid of.

More importantly, we need to get a new deal for Potter sorted before we start considering the players imo.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 7:37 pm  

Speed is of the essence. Contracts started to be arranged a couple of weeks ago and are usually sorted by the end of the month. Other clubs have been quite open about making offers to our best 16 &17yo's as they know we are strapped for cash.

Re: Who should we keep and who should we sell? : Sun Jun 10, 2012 7:48 pm  

[
More importantly, we need to get a new deal for Potter sorted before we start considering the players imo.[/quote]

Toatally agree!!!