Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Wed Oct 01, 2014 7:44 pm  

goobervision wrote:

I'm surprised that Smith or Lockers don't get a mention as they have both been outstanding players this year for Wigan. Most despised team? If that were the case why are Hanley and Farrel in the list of past winners when arguably they played for a more dominant and more "despised' period of the Wigan team?

Don't forget this is the Player's Player of the season. I personally don't think that Peacock or Roby are deserving (is Peacock there at respect of his age and continuing?) I haven't seen enough of Hill to really comment and Clarke has been a cracking player but doesn't shine when Cas have been struggling.

O'Loughlin has only played around about half the season.

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Thu Oct 02, 2014 7:50 am  

There's a whole thread on this forum of Warrington fans falling out of their trees complaining about the Man of Steel nominations.

Maybe Wane should shut up and repeat the RFL mantra

Jamie Peacock is the best player in Super League
Jamie Peacock is the best player in Super League
or maybe James Roby

if anybody disagrees there's video evidence going back 5 to 10 years to prove it.

I expect the RFL would tell us that Wigans players are all non-entities which will cause an embarassing shuffle if they win SL again this year and have taken 3 of the last 4 trophies...ah well they can always give Wane coach of the year and say the only reason they are successful is because they have a coaching genius.

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Thu Oct 02, 2014 1:19 pm  

sally cinnamon wrote:

..ah well they can always give Wane coach of the year and say the only reason they are successful is because they have a coaching genius.

Personally, I believe Wane is the difference between this Wigan side actually being pretty mediocre compared to the SL favourites they presently are.

His backs-to-the-wall, get-stuck-in tactics might not be to everybody's taste but they work effectively - It might be pushing it, but he knows how to polish a turd and does it well.

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Thu Oct 02, 2014 6:04 pm  

Saddened! wrote: I'd still much rather lose this game gracefully than get to the Final. I can't face another trip to OT and seeing them lose to Wigan, or especially Warrington. over here: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=575083&start=30 Could it be that Warrington are the most despised?

Saddened! wrote: I'd still much rather lose this game gracefully than get to the Final. I can't face another trip to OT and seeing them lose to Wigan, or especially Warrington. over here: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=575083&start=30 Could it be that Warrington are the most despised?

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Thu Oct 02, 2014 6:21 pm  

goobervision wrote: over here: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=575083&start=30 Could it be that Warrington are the most despised? Saddo is full of s**t. You would have thought people would have realised that by now.

goobervision wrote: over here: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=575083&start=30 Could it be that Warrington are the most despised? Saddo is full of s**t. You would have thought people would have realised that by now.

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Thu Oct 02, 2014 7:49 pm  

sally cinnamon wrote:

There's a whole thread on this forum of Warrington fans falling out of their trees complaining about the Man of Steel nominations.

Maybe Wane should shut up and repeat the RFL mantra

Jamie Peacock is the best player in Super League
Jamie Peacock is the best player in Super League
or maybe James Roby

if anybody disagrees there's video evidence going back 5 to 10 years to prove it.

I expect the RFL would tell us that Wigans players are all non-entities which will cause an embarassing shuffle if they win SL again this year and have taken 3 of the last 4 trophies...ah well they can always give Wane coach of the year and say the only reason they are successful is because they have a coaching genius.

You do you realise MoS is voted for by the players?

Re: Shauh Wane falls out of his tree : Fri Oct 03, 2014 10:57 am  

I find it amazing the number of people who simply don't understand journalism. In a press conference a journalist asks if Wane thinks any Wigan players should have been included in the short list for MOS. What do you expect the Wigan coach to say? No, none of my players are good enough, they're all rubbish really.

He responds "I thought Matty would have had a chance with what he has done when (half-back partner) Blake Green has been out," Wane said. A fair enough comment then turned into a non-story by other journalists.