Re: Francis Cummings : Fri Sep 19, 2014 11:33 am  

Bulliac wrote:

Well, Carvell and Winterstein were two Franny brought to the club, so that argument doesn't really stack up there. They, and the others, quoted worries about finances going forward, their families coming first etc, of course they may have been being somewhat disingenuous..

There have been plenty of crap coaches who have lured good players to a club. When they get there the challenge really starts. I can't think of many players who moved on citing a crap coach, it is the usual clichés as you say. Generally it is to win more games &/or trophies. I am sure there is some of that in Lowes ability to attract SL quality players for next season.

Re: Francis Cummings : Fri Sep 19, 2014 1:13 pm  

Cumming shouldn't complain. He could have been a Chinese newsreader, and got sacked for mistaking the visiting Chinese president Xi Jinping's name for the Roman numeral XI, calling him "Eleven Jinping" on air. Do they have Tlibunars in China?

Cumming shouldn't complain. He could have been a Chinese newsreader, and got sacked for mistaking the visiting Chinese president Xi Jinping's name for the Roman numeral XI, calling him "Eleven Jinping" on air. Do they have Tlibunars in China?

Re: Francis Cummings : Fri Sep 19, 2014 1:59 pm  

Northernrelic wrote:

His employment rights would accrue from when he first went on the payroll as assistant coach which was I think before April 2012 when the entitlement period moved from one to two years.

)

His time as assistant coach is irrelevant. He was made redundant from that role in the first administration. He then volunteered for free until being re-employed as head coach by Ok, which is when his continuous service would start. His assistant coaches contract was terminated by guilfoyle. It wasn't tupe'd over to OK bulls like the players.

Re: Francis Cummings : Sun Sep 21, 2014 10:57 am  

He is one of those guys who needs to lower his profile for a while and get back to basic coaching he was out of his depth at Bradford, a spell buiding a champioship side might do him good, a bit like Powell. I doubt a big club will take him on as a head coach any time soon.

Re: Francis Cummings : Mon Sep 22, 2014 7:14 am  

mat wrote:

His time as assistant coach is irrelevant. He was made redundant from that role in the first administration. He then volunteered for free until being re-employed as head coach by Ok, which is when his continuous service would start. His assistant coaches contract was terminated by guilfoyle. It wasn't tupe'd over to OK bulls like the players.

Good point - though the way he was treated above while reducing his legal entitlement to me at least makes him more deserving of a settlement.

Treating people equitably is an investment, look at how Powell's credit has risen at Cas, who knows where FC could be in the future?

Re: Francis Cummings : Mon Sep 22, 2014 12:44 pm  

Northernrelic wrote:

Good point - though the way he was treated above while reducing his legal entitlement to me at least makes him more deserving of a settlement.

Treating people equitably is an investment, look at how Powell's credit has risen at Cas, who knows where FC could be in the future?

Agree with that entirely. I was just talking about clubs legal obligations. Morally I think he should get a settlement. It was mentioned in original article that club had tried to come to an agreement but had failed. So maybe its a case of him wanting full 15 months wages and club offering significantly less. Think its been a bit of PR own goal and they would have been better paying full amount just to prevent bad publicity.

Re: Francis Cummings : Thu Sep 25, 2014 4:27 pm  

Francis Cummings is being tipped to take over at Halifax, should make for an interesting match up.

Re: Francis Cummings : Thu Sep 25, 2014 8:38 pm  

bulldozer II wrote:

He is one of those guys who needs to lower his profile for a while and get back to basic coaching he was out of his depth at Bradford, a spell buiding a champioship side might do him good, a bit like Powell. I doubt a big club will take him on as a head coach any time soon.

Having more than three props in the entire squad let alone able to play on match day, might do him some good. Last season we had more props than this, and it inspired one poster to assert that the modern game did not require props, just a load of second rowers. This season has proved him entirely wrong. How would any of the top teams fare with three props in their squad?

And why have we got SIX props in next years squad? bit of a difference, three and six? Of course the proof is when FC gets another chance, does he get rid of three of the six props in the squad because thats what he wants?

Dont forget, last season the only reason he didnt get us to the payoffs was the points deduction.

So I think you need to lower your profile a while and get back to basic facts, you are clearly out of your depth on a Bulls forum, a spell watching a balanced squad might do you some good, something every other poster on here already appreciates. I doubt that any sensible forum will take on board your comments any time soon.

Re: Francis Cummings : Thu Sep 25, 2014 9:24 pm  

Martin we had no points deduction in 2013. It was 2012 and Potter was coach

Re: Francis Cummings : Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:39 am  

grattanboy wrote:

Francis Cummings is being tipped to take over at Halifax, should make for an interesting match up.

FC didn't get the Fax coaching job in the end.

Also off topic, but interesting to see that Jamie Langley has signed for Sheffield next season, so we'll be seeing him back at Odsal after all (if he isn't injured by then).