Board index ‹ Super League ‹ St. Helens - the-entertainers.tv ‹ Rumours thread.

Lee gilmour signed for cas. (like I said 2 weeks ago)

Pete why dont you change your username to "told you 2 weeks ago"

And how come you never tell us 8 days ago, or 3 weeks ago?

Saint77777 wrote:

Pete why dont you change your username to "told you 2 weeks ago"

And how come you never tell us 8 days ago, or 3 weeks ago?

I think it was nearer two weeks ago posted or pm

Why don't you change your name to stalker as you seen to follow me about.

[Offside Monkey]

Is craig hall worth a punt on the wing?
He's had a bit of an up and down career, but he has definate qualities and I'm led to beleive has been showing good form and consitancy throughout this season?
What do people think of him compared to, say, Josh Griffin?

Offside Monkey wrote:

Is craig hall worth a punt on the wing?
He's had a bit of an up and down career, but he has definate qualities and I'm led to beleive has been showing good form and consitancy throughout this season?
What do people think of him compared to, say, Josh Griffin?

I've wondered about Hall. He has played some really good rugby this year, but most of that seems to have been when he was filling in at stand off. His versatility would be an assett, but for a player who was touted for such good things to be apparently so unwanted suggests to me that there must be something badly wrong either with his game or his attitude.

I've not seen anything in Josh Griffin to make me think he'd be worth signing. He's reasonably big and reasonably quick, but from what I've seen is every bit as error prone as Meli and a worse defender.

Offside Monkey wrote:

Is craig hall worth a punt on the wing?
He's had a bit of an up and down career, but he has definate qualities and I'm led to beleive has been showing good form and consitancy throughout this season?
What do people think of him compared to, say, Josh Griffin?

Hall,yes. Griffin,no way.

[Sheldon]

Dux wrote:

I've wondered about Hall. He has played some really good rugby this year, but most of that seems to have been when he was filling in at stand off. His versatility would be an assett, but for a player who was touted for such good things to be apparently so unwanted suggests to me that there must be something badly wrong either with his game or his attitude.

I've not seen anything in Josh Griffin to make me think he'd be worth signing. He's reasonably big and reasonably quick, but from what I've seen is every bit as error prone as Meli and a worse defender.

Nothing wrong with his attitude.

Sheldon wrote:

Nothing wrong with his attitude.

What would you say were his main weaknesses?

Dux wrote:

What would you say were his main weaknesses?

When he was at Hull, one of his downfalls imo was that he tried too hard sometimes. Also a lack of concentration was a factor aswell.

Sounds like Sully.