Board index ‹ Super League ‹ Hull FC - blackandwhites.co.uk ‹ Rumours Redux

R.B.A wrote:

Perhaps, but maybe we may find that Ratchford is better than Hodgson, Bowden better than Moa, Green better than Clinton, Jones better than Meli, Russell better than Roberts etc..

Brett Hodgson won MOS. Moa can get a gig in the NRL, I like Bowden a lot but will he ever break tackles like Moa does? Would guess more than likely not. Not seen enough of Green and Clinton to compare. You're wilfully missing the point here. The best players in our competition over the last few years have either been the highest paid overseas ones (Hodgson, Monaghan etc) or British players capable of an NRL contract like Graham and Burgess. Even if you say we can replace the more mediocre overseas players with young British players, which I don't necessarily disagree with, the fact remains that the Leuleuias, Morleys and Finches of this world, ie players who would have played here but are good enough to earn a lot more in the NRL, will be lost to SL. We will see more British players getting SL deals, a good thing, but taking out the top slice of players will reduce the overall standard of RL being played.

Mrs Barista wrote:

Brett Hodgson won MOS. Moa can get a gig in the NRL, I like Bowden a lot but will he ever break tackles like Moa does? Would guess more than likely not. Not seen enough of Green and Clinton to compare. You're wilfully missing the point here. The best players in our competition over the last few years have either been the highest paid overseas ones (Hodgson, Monaghan etc) or British players capable of an NRL contract like Graham and Burgess. Even if you say we can replace the more mediocre overseas players with young British players, which I don't necessarily disagree with, the fact remains that the Leuleuias, Morleys and Finches of this world, ie players who would have played here but are good enough to earn a lot more in the NRL, will be lost to SL. We will see more British players getting SL deals, a good thing, but taking out the top slice of players will reduce the overall standard of RL being played.

You do realise Morley's English, don't you? Just that's twice he's been in your list of players lost to the NRL.

east hull FC fan wrote:

You do realise Morley's English, don't you? Just that's twice he's been in your list of players lost to the NRL.

Yes, my point is that he was a player good enough to go play in Aus but came back with a few years left to a comparable wage. Things have moved on now, the gap is wider and I think he'd have been more likely to stay over there had there been the current differential. Not only will Aussie players be less likely to come here, the top Brits will find it more attractive to go there, diluting the quality of our competition overall.

Mrs Barista wrote:

Yes, my point is that he was a player good enough to go play in Aus but came back with a few years left to a comparable wage. Things have moved on now, the gap is wider and I think he'd have been more likely to stay over there had there been the current differential. Not only will Aussie players be less likely to come here, the top Brits will find it more attractive to go there, diluting the quality of our competition overall.

Ah right. Don't care really, we already watch an inferior league and our players will improve playing in the NRL which will help our national team. Slight dilution, while lowering the quality won't stop the excitement.

Mrs Barista wrote:

Yes, my point is that he was a player good enough to go play in Aus but came back with a few years left to a comparable wage. Things have moved on now, the gap is wider and I think he'd have been more likely to stay over there had there been the current differential. Not only will Aussie players be less likely to come here, the top Brits will find it more attractive to go there, diluting the quality of our competition overall.

It was always going to come though , I can see the SL been reduced in the not to distant future .

Mrs Barista wrote:

I still think the overall quality of the competition will be diluted in the next couple of years as Leuleuais (Tommy and Kylie), Finch, Brett Hodgson, Menzies, Morley etc depart and are replaced by younger British players with a lack of genuine homegrown talent.

I agree and I think the only viable solution to this would be for the RFL to seriously consider going down to at least 12 teams in SL...although I suppose it's easy for the likes of us (Saints) and yourselves to say as we are more than likely guaranteed to be safe.

[Sheldon]

With less of average overseas players clogging up the league we'll be able to keep hold of our young players who go to union.

Aston, Tomkins, Eastmond, Smith, Walker, Myler, Farrell would have never left the game.

B0NES wrote:

It was always going to come though , I can see the SL been reduced in the not to distant future .

That's short-termism and an admission of defeat. If the Aussies had thought that way in the 1970s, we'd still be beating them at test level and most likely playing boring rugby.

The solution is not to reduce the number of elite clubs, it is to expand the pool of players to select from and nurture them into elite players

Came here looking for some rumours, must have taken a wrong turn.

Any truthin the rumour that we have signed a dobbins player on a 2 yr deal , ? Poss lovegrove