Re: Mamo : Tue Apr 10, 2018 6:17 pm  

djhudds wrote:

Tyllar is not and will not be a super league full back, Tyllar a a great kid but he isn’t super league standard

Neither were the king brothers..... oh hang on.....
Not sure how you can make that statement at this point in time regarding Tylar. For me he’s a stand out player in the U19s, so that doesn’t say much for the rest of them.... Oh hang on- aren’t they doing really well....
full back is the most difficult position to play, you don’t get many kids stepping up to play SL at 18 in the full back role.
From what I e seen He can certainly catch and throw a ball better than Mamo!

Re: Mamo : Tue Apr 10, 2018 10:51 pm  

1 he’s 19
2 he plays wing if louis isn’t available
3 he’s had a lot of injuries
4 he’s not a stand out in 19’s
5 he said himself can he play wing as he’s not comfortable
Is that ok ?
I know it won’t so by all means come back with your usual expert opinion

Re: Mamo : Tue Apr 10, 2018 11:06 pm  

Notice no comment about him being able to catch and pass better than Mamo.
Will have to agree to disagree about whether he has what it takes.

Re: Mamo : Wed Apr 11, 2018 12:01 am  

Yes he can catch better than Mamo but so can most
Can he pass better than mamo, debateable as both are poor
When everyone fit he’s third choice fullback for 19’s
I love tyllar and wish he would be our next fullback but he isn’t good enough

Re: Mamo : Wed Apr 11, 2018 6:32 pm  

I think he played very well with Faz, they had a good understanding. I do t think he’s been as effective since Faz moved on.
We will have to see whether he has what it takes long term- but as I say I’d rather spend the money on our own youngsters than a big wedge on a third rate Aussie.