Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 1:46 pm  

Eastern Wildcat wrote:

In my eyes Wilzay, the play that ended in that error, should have been closed down well before it got to that kick!

You could the same about any other situation where the full back is exposed. ATEOTD, Grix is experienced and he made one of the biggest cock ups, like the young Hull fullback did for MCBs try. So you can't really point out the errors Jowitt makes when the first choice is equally if not more prone to brain farts.

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 1:58 pm  

Willzay wrote:

You could the same about any other situation where the full back is exposed. ATEOTD, Grix is experienced and he made one of the biggest cock ups, like the young Hull fullback did for MCBs try. So you can't really point out the errors Jowitt makes when the first choice is equally if not more prone to brain farts.

You're doing exactly the same by saying "if not more prone to brain farts". I can point out whatever I like, it happened and it's effected my opinion. If you're opinion is that Grix is worse or to quote more prone to brain farts; then that's your opinion.

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 2:19 pm  

Hooley off to Oldham on loan

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 2:20 pm  

NEwildcat wrote:

Hooley off to Oldham on loan

Get the lad some experience, good move. In Chezzy we trust.

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 2:24 pm  

Wonder how Jowitt would have developed if he'd had a 2nd full season of 1st team experience behind him?

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 2:45 pm  

Trinity18 wrote:

I stand corrected, never even heard of that though.

Does it really count if it's run by the Rugby Leaguer & League Express?

Which is obviously a joke, credit to Max - my opinion is still my opinion and will be until he changes that. It seems people are presuming I don't have any respect for him at all, as I've previously stated I rate him in attack, it's his defensive efforts and confidence under a high ball that bothers me. Two errors in two games that have both led to tries that should back my point up.

So number18 because you've never heard of it, it doesn't count, and because it's sponsored by the League Express it's obviously a joke, in what way does it make it so.

Things only become obvious to people who are of the same opinion, and as most peoples opinion of Max Jowitt differs to yours it's far from obvious, your opinion on here is obviously highly rated and maybe when Max's time comes he may just get you to change your opinion, maybe eh.

Re: Retiring Players : Wed Apr 11, 2018 3:23 pm  

Fullback is the most unforgiving position in the team, might have lifted that off Barry Mac in the Catalans game on Saturday!
Every error is magnified.
For me the team is at a crossroads, you have Finn and Grix at 33/34, at some point you have to replace them.
Hampshire has been pushed from pillar to post at his previous clubs,he's now come 'home' and should be allowed to continue in the SH role until his form drops, same goes for Max.
I think the reason our attack hasn't clicked this season so far,is because Grix seems to be half a yard behind where he should be compared with last season.
You could see when Max joined into the line and threw a cutout ball for Tupou's try at Hull,that had Grix written all over it.