Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Fri Aug 01, 2014 9:35 pm  

Listening to the game last night on Radio Manchester you would have thought that the ref got every decision wrong.The pundits swore that the first try was not grounded etc. I got to see the game this morning on TV and the vast majority of calls seemed correct. The only one that really suprised me was the last try when Smith clearly gets the ball on the inside shoulder and runs round behind the passer blocking an attempted tackle. As for the Lockers slide tackle a penalty would have been justified rather than the hang drawn and quatering that some are calling for.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Fri Aug 01, 2014 10:41 pm  

Cronus wrote:

When 3 referees see nothing wrong with it, and 2 of those have had chance to review it several times from several angles, I'm happy to accept they are, on balance, most likely correct.

There have been several occasions where Cummings has disagreed with the game officials. On this they all agreed.

I'll take that over untrained rl fans.

They were still wrong. Either that or their decisions earlier in the season, when 3 referees, 2 of whom had chance to review it several times from several angles, were wrong.

A couple of obstruction calls given tonight in the Leeds v Bradford game, both for running round the back of a man who doesn't get involved in the defensive line.

Having said that the ref was terrible tonight.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Fri Aug 01, 2014 11:26 pm  

Him wrote:

They were still wrong. Either that or their decisions earlier in the season, when 3 referees, 2 of whom had chance to review it several times from several angles, were wrong.

Again, no offence but I'll take their opinions over yours, unless of course you've completed the SL refereeing courses and have the equivalent of their combined experience?

Having said that the ref was terrible tonight.

Well we all assumed that. Leeds lost didn't they?

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Sat Aug 02, 2014 9:03 am  

Not sure about anything else but the run around was 100% an obstruction. He ran round the back of his own player with the ball in hand. How can it not be?

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Sat Aug 02, 2014 1:33 pm  

Cronus wrote:

Again, no offence but I'll take their opinions over yours, unless of course you've completed the SL refereeing courses and have the equivalent of their combined experience?

Well we all assumed that. Leeds lost didn't they?

I didn't actually mean it in that way. We deserved to lose, we were bloody awful.
In the weather conditions the last thing that game last night needed was a ref who allowed both sides to hold down and be offside. It meant the defences were up incredibly quickly and led to rushed passes and even more knock ons than there would've been.
The reffing turned what might have been an average game into a poor one.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Sun Aug 03, 2014 8:22 am  

Eastbourne Warrior wrote:

To be fair it's not just Wigan. Leeds attract a similar amount of attention on here.

Mad that. Two of the biggest and well supported teams in the league get the most attention on fans forums. You would never have thought it.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Sun Aug 03, 2014 7:00 pm  

Only just seen the "football tackle", missed it during the game. Not sure what to make of it tbh, it's an unusual challenge. Looks like he won the ball and the ref was satisfied that there had been no foul play. Could have been different if it had been mis-timed though.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Tue Aug 05, 2014 8:53 am  

Because it was asked earlier and not bee answered, if a goal line drop out is not taken correctly then the receiving team get a penalty 10 metres from the goal line.

Re: Sean O loughlin football tackles chase : Tue Aug 05, 2014 9:40 am