Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 12:16 pm  

AscotAsh wrote:

As good as it is for the spectator, it must be pretty frustrating for the likes of top 4 playing each other up to 5 times (2 x league, 1 x super 8's, 1 x top 4 fight off and potentially 1 x Challenge Cup). Add in to the mix pre-season friendlies etc and this is now a bit silly.

Could be 6 with magic weekend.

Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 12:27 pm  

AscotAsh wrote:

This is exactly what Hudgell was mentioning on Dumberside a couple of weeks ago.

What's it got to do with him???

I think if we were Leeds (god forbid) we wouldn't be having this discussion, but I think it might need a rejig for next year, based on the arguments here. Every minute counts for some, but not others at the moment

Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 2:12 pm  

Maybe the answer is to have a separate competition before the split and to keep the incentive to win matches the RFL share a payment between the top four sides on the basis of where you finish.The top four would also enter the challenge cup one round later than usual.
That would then enable the super 8 competition to start with all teams on zero points with a lot more interest for the lower finishing teams.

Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 2:38 pm  

How about halving the points going into the 8? Makes it closer but doesn't erase a team's performance in the regular season.

Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 3:49 pm  

Chris28 wrote:

What's it got to do with him???

I think if we were Leeds (god forbid) we wouldn't be having this discussion, but I think it might need a rejig for next year, based on the arguments here. Every minute counts for some, but not others at the moment

Don't think it should be revised so quickly. Emphasis should be on 6th, 7th & 8th to do better, surely?

Re: Super 8's points : Fri Aug 21, 2015 3:51 pm  

C for Cuckoo wrote:

How about halving the points going into the 8? Makes it closer but doesn't erase a team's performance in the regular season.

We don't want decimal points do we? Not really ideal.

Re: Super 8's points : Sat Aug 22, 2015 4:30 pm  

Going 8th then after today, same points as Catalans and Wire but worse points difference. Good to see Catalans hit some form, they've really underperformed this season.

Re: Super 8's points : Sat Aug 22, 2015 4:41 pm  

fc baldy wrote:

Anyone else feel that they should have started with everyone on zero pts to make it a lot more interesting,the powers that be said it would be more competitive,there are 5 clubs going for top 4 with the other 3 plodding along with no chance whatsoever of getting top 4 due to points adrift.Mind you,would have been good just to hear the sky mob spluttering a outs Sts being beaten 3 times and bottom if gone on zero points.

Would you be saying that if Hull finished 4th and were reset to zero along with a team who finish 8/10 points behind you?

If Hull didn't want these last 3/4 games to be meaningless then they should've won more games in he regular season....not relay on a technicality to level the points up.

Re: Super 8's points : Sat Aug 22, 2015 4:51 pm  

Same weakness as the 8-team play off under the previous format IMO. The lower teams are no more likely to make an impact now than they were then, regardless of whether the points are reset to zero or not.

Re: Super 8's points : Sat Aug 22, 2015 8:01 pm  

Agree with Mrs B. It was always likely that Cats would win some of their home games and make it difficult for us to hold onto 7th.
We can still do it, but we need to find an 80 minute intensity we've been missing all season.