I would be looking at the whole season, Finn and Miller were terrible at the start at least the first 6 rounds and have reverted to terrible for the last 6 matches. How players who have played so poorly in half the games can even be considered for player of the year is beyond me. As a squad over the last several years we have the ability for standards to drop to a really poor standard, how one game such as Huddersfield away in the cup they can defend like their lives depend on it then another game they cannot be bothered suggests lack of professionalism. So for me my player of the year has to be someone who has played to a high standard week in week out despite the carnage going on around him, a player who has improved, a durable player, a player who looks like he cares, so for me it can only be Anderson.
If not Anderson then Max Jowitt is the only player who meets my criteria.