He was wrong about the ref. He seemed to get things right and wrong for both teams.
As for the concept, what was his point? Should be the top 4 of the middle 8's to stay up? Bulls stay down. Winner of Championship comes up? Didn't Leigh win it? What he blew was the chance of a home fixture (although he probably expected us to beat Sheffield).
The big problem for Bradford is that they may not get as good a chance as that. They are blessed with a couple of players who are too good for the league (Purtell and Gaskell) and will never meet a poorer side.
The bigger risk to the format is that the Super League clubs smash the Championship sides for 7 games but then a Championship club comes up for just one good day. Perhaps the best format is simply to have it as top 4 stay up out of middle 8's. But then again, the excitement could be lost early on.