Pie Eyed wrote:
Brett.
It's all about functional strength.
The guy who lifts the heaviest weights in any gym is generalyy regarded as the strongest.
However, ask him how many pull-ups or chin-ups he can do on a bar and most of these guys will struggle.
Pit them against a climber, whose main strength lies in low-bulk, "sinewy" strength and the smaller man will win every time.
For the same reason, we don't want our players to simply be the strongest, otherwise you'd have a team full of Mariusz Pudzianowski's.
They'd be strong, but NOT quick, NOT mobile, NOT able to do 90% of their job.
They need the RIGHT strength for the job - That means both the right amount and the right type.
It's all about functional strength.
The guy who lifts the heaviest weights in any gym is generalyy regarded as the strongest.
However, ask him how many pull-ups or chin-ups he can do on a bar and most of these guys will struggle.
Pit them against a climber, whose main strength lies in low-bulk, "sinewy" strength and the smaller man will win every time.
For the same reason, we don't want our players to simply be the strongest, otherwise you'd have a team full of Mariusz Pudzianowski's.
They'd be strong, but NOT quick, NOT mobile, NOT able to do 90% of their job.
They need the RIGHT strength for the job - That means both the right amount and the right type.
You are getting confused here Pie Eyed,
The pullups analogy is a bad one. e.g. Take a 23stone prop who couldn't achieve one pullup and pit him against a 11 stone guy who can do 100. Who is going to come off worse?
Tbh if our front row were the same build as Pudzianwhatshisface then I wouldn't be unhappy!
There is a trade off ofc between weight and the ability to run all day. That applies to muscle and fat, but that's not the point being made.
Jonh's point ( I think) was that a foundation of "basic strength" is best when it's "topped up" with exercises that better simulate the specific demands of a game of RL.
I would argue whilst that is true to an extent, I would rather focus on the effort of the individual and if that effort was directed into "basic" exercises, then so be it.