Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 7:28 am  

CW8 wrote:

Hill probably because he hasnt been awful just not his best, he has had a lot going on and hasn't spent that long with the new coaches. He definitely needs to sort his discipline though, been very poor to see our captain losing his cool.

Westwood is long in the tooth, maybe we would be better playing someone else off the bench, my feeling is he will be covering prop in case we have any injuries.

Patton seems to be a young player without any confidence, he doesn't get involved enough, however he isn't going to gain any confidence sitting on the benches so it's a tough call. He doesn't seem to be mentally there at this stage though and probably doesn't deserve to be playing if others are fit.

Ive got to take issue with your inclusion of lineham, he may not be everyone's perfect winger but he went pretty well last season in a terrible team and by the sound of things was our man of the match last week as well as scoring the week before. What does he have to do to get any credit? I think he would be one of the first names on the team sheet at the minute and will be our top try score come the end of the season. We have problems on the right edge and pretty much everywhere else but the left edge is so far the least worrying part of our team.

I take your point with Hill not being himself, but on form he’s playing at the same level as Cooper. Except Cooper seems to give away less penalties. Let’s face facts, we have 2 props, after Hill and Cooper it’s the best of the rest to plug the gap until they can come back on.

Westwood is too slow to play out wide and ineffective in the middle. There’s nowhere left for him to play. Sentimental selection.

Pattons issues are confidence yet Browns aren’t, yet Brown has proven he can deliver but Patton hasn’t? Brown was the figurehead of last seasons frustration, everyone got on his back and he copped a bit for the teams form.

Lineham, maybe through no fault of his own, has no game sense. Against Leeds the flop and the blatant 3 on 1 steal were absolutely stupid. Don’t get me wrong, he does score, but if that was the only grading criteria Penny would be considered a SL winger. People say he’s ‘raw’ but he’s been here for 2 years, and Hull for a period before that, he’s half way through his career, it’s not an excuse anymore. Drawing a big salary for a little return.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 10:08 am  

I sort of agree with you on everyone but lineham because IMO He isn't our problem, or at least if he is a problem he is a long way down our list of problems as he is one of the few who seem to be doing a decent job at the minute.

Trouble with your synopsis though is we can't drop everybody, so the question is which players should price drop that will shock the squad enough to give them a kick up the backside. For me it would be Hill for his petulance and ratchford for his poor start to the season. I would also drop Russell but I don't think dropping Russell would shock the squad enough for it to be considered a wake up call. To be fair you could just strip Hill of captaincy and it would probably wake him up and shock the squad a bit.

Maybe choose a new captain v widnes and drop ratchford to the bench? I am glad it's not me who has to make these decisions but I really hope he doesn't stick with the same team again they don't deserve it.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 10:45 am  

CW8 wrote:

I sort of agree with you on everyone but lineham because IMO He isn't our problem, or at least if he is a problem he is a long way down our list of problems as he is one of the few who seem to be doing a decent job at the minute.

Trouble with your synopsis though is we can't drop everybody, so the question is which players should price drop that will shock the squad enough to give them a kick up the backside. For me it would be Hill for his petulance and ratchford for his poor start to the season. I would also drop Russell but I don't think dropping Russell would shock the squad enough for it to be considered a wake up call. To be fair you could just strip Hill of captaincy and it would probably wake him up and shock the squad a bit.

Maybe choose a new captain v widnes and drop ratchford to the bench? I am glad it's not me who has to make these decisions but I really hope he doesn't stick with the same team again they don't deserve it.

I’m not saying we drop anyone, just saying that there are players in comparable form to those you listed to be dropped.

What I would like to happen is for the whole club to pull together and really get behind the 13 out on the field, and release this tension. But if we couldn’t do that for Smith last year, I can’t see it being done for Price now. Realistically we need to win Friday, otherwise it’s going to be a toxic atmosphere at the Wigan game.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 11:33 am  

Barbed Wire wrote:

I’m not saying we drop anyone, just saying that there are players in comparable form to those you listed to be dropped.

What I would like to happen is for the whole club to pull together and really get behind the 13 out on the field, and release this tension. But if we couldn’t do that for Smith last year, I can’t see it being done for Price now. Realistically we need to win Friday, otherwise it’s going to be a toxic atmosphere at the Wigan game.

Wasn't me who listed players to be dropped earlier, you were responding to someone else. I agree with you to be honest, apologies i thought you were suggesting we should drop even more than were listed earlier. I was responding to my feelings on those players that you listed and probably wouldn't have responded had lineham been left out of it.

I do feel a little shake up is required. Price said last Thursday was unacceptable, if they perform the same again this Friday and he hasn't changed anything then he will probably have to act for the wigan game. Like you said the atmosphere wouldn't be great and I think the home crowd figures will fall rapidly too.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 11:45 am  

I’d love to know how we suddenly got to this state at the start of last year. There doesn’t seem to be any one reason, just that the grand final loss started a rut that we can’t get out of. Also that we haven’t replaced players appropriately, or the replacements haven’t realised the potential shown. We weren’t great in 2016 I know, we were just good in a poor league. However, there’s no reason we should end up as bad as we currently are. It’s bewildering...

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 11:57 am  

easyWire wrote:

I’d love to know how we suddenly got to this state at the start of last year. There doesn’t seem to be any one reason, just that the grand final loss started a rut that we can’t get out of. Also that we haven’t replaced players appropriately, or the replacements haven’t realised the potential shown. We weren’t great in 2016 I know, we were just good in a poor league. However, there’s no reason we should end up as bad as we currently are. It’s bewildering...

I know it's puzzling. The Brisbane game we looked great then since then we have not played well again to this date.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 12:24 pm  

easyWire wrote:

I’d love to know how we suddenly got to this state at the start of last year. There doesn’t seem to be any one reason, just that the grand final loss started a rut that we can’t get out of. Also that we haven’t replaced players appropriately, or the replacements haven’t realised the potential shown. We weren’t great in 2016 I know, we were just good in a poor league. However, there’s no reason we should end up as bad as we currently are. It’s bewildering...

2015 - W11 L12 D0
2016 - W16 L6 D1
2017 - W9 L12 D2

(23 regular season games)

Your spot on with the recruitment / decline in player quality, but I don't think we suddenly got to this state at the start of 2017. We're actually pretty consistent over the past few seasons. 2016 was a bump because we signed the Sandow/Gidley partnership, which was enough to give us those crucial extra wins (plus the quality of the league that season was not the best).

Overall, SL is that close (crap in quality), that a matter of a couple of wins difference can send you from relegation to pushing the playoff places.

Last season, Leeds were champions, from 2nd place. They lost A THIRD of their games. Imagine that. They lose 1 in every 3, yet still finish 2nd and get in the GF. That's cack. In RU, the top 2 teams in the league that contested the GF both lost just 4/22.

I still think we can get top 4, not because we're going to suddenly replicate our 2011 form, but because we don't need to.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 12:46 pm  

You make a good point. In fact when you look at a typical 2016 match day 17 and the match day 17 from last week its only the half back positions where the playing quality differs greatly

i.e. 2016 was very much down to Sandow and Gidley

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 12:47 pm  

Price “hmmm I’m sure someone said I would have a honeymoon period”.

Re: Price - I wonder what he is thinking? : Wed Feb 14, 2018 12:57 pm  

I see in todays paper Price is quoted saying Warrington are 'on track' despite losing your first two games.

Obviously he thinks it's going to be 'your year' as well.