Surrounding the ref : Sun Apr 26, 2015 3:43 pm  

After watching the game on Friday night it was clear that the Leeds players were more interested in talking to the ref than playing the game. This slowly creeping in and when he pulled Mcguire to one side to have a word with him he specifically said this is the forth time I'm doing this. If that is the case shouldn't players be binned or sent off? I really don't want this game to go the way of football. Hopefully the RFL will start doing something about it.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Sun Apr 26, 2015 3:48 pm  

They did the same last time we played them, just after Penny scored.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Sun Apr 26, 2015 3:51 pm  

The refs are becoming weak to this.

I'm sick of seeing it. It's been in the game for a few years now, I remember James Graham clearly shouting "F off you F'ing c***" with proper anger at Thierry Alibert. A number of Leeds players used to be at it a lot when McLennan was coach. And STomkins does it a fair bit.

The other night when Maguire shouted something at the ref and then he took Maguire and Sinfield to one side and Maguire said "it's not about you, you know"...he should have said "right, son, ten minutes, don't speak to me like that".

Yet the refs just ignore a lot of it.

It needs clamping down on big time, for me.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Sun Apr 26, 2015 4:08 pm  

It's an odd development. Unlike in football, we as fans would all be delighted to see players from every team panned for this- marched ten to start with, then binned for further and a red for Hock-style manhandling. Of course, it would have to be done consistently.

However, referees seem to want to make excuses for players. Cummings always manages to find a reason to laugh it off, as does Silverwood. Thaler and Child tend to ignore it - which is better, but insufficient.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Sun Apr 26, 2015 4:10 pm  

Nothing has been done since the days of Cunningham,Wellans,Long and Sculthorpe.. They were pioneers of it..

Re: Surrounding the ref : Mon Apr 27, 2015 7:17 am  

The game of Rugby League could do something about this if it really wanted to. It would be doing the whole of society a big favour. We sell our game that it shows discipline and self control but I'm afraid standards are now low. You rarely see the referee tapping his lips and marching an extra ten yards ... and then another ten as the player fails to shut up. Refs. still have the power but they are failing us. They need to be told to get a grip of the game. You can't beat a bit of immediate and effective discipline ... the players would learn like a shot.
I can remember our PE teacher (many years back) during a lesson marching us back in six stages of ten yards as we "complained" about a decision. It's stuck with me for ever.
It can be done ... we need to bring self control and discipline back onto our game.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Mon Apr 27, 2015 11:51 am  

Yes agree with this.
The clubs need to instill in players the way to behave on a rugby pitch - unlike football.

Only in exceptional circumstances should anyone other than the captain be able to talk back to the ref. Otherwise 10 yard pen, or for Maguire type persistence - 10mins in the bin.
Surrounding the ref - yellow card
Touching or grabbing the ref - red card

Graham type swearing at the ref - multiple game ban.

I'm proud of RL's reputation compared the those who play the round ball.
Standards have slipped bu they are recoverable.

[Winslade's Offload]

Re: Surrounding the ref : Mon Apr 27, 2015 12:20 pm  

I agree, it is something that the refs need to sort out. But there is another way of looking at it though; when I played the game and it happened, I always interpreted it as the player(s) getting flustered and losing control. For me that was all the encouragement I needed to hit them even faster and harder in the tackle, and to force more errors out of them. By acting like Mags last week, they are simply doing our job for us.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Mon Apr 27, 2015 1:22 pm  

fez1 wrote:

Touching or grabbing the ref - red card

This is a bit of a grey area. You have the likes of Gareth Hock that knocked over Thaler I think it was, got a ban.

Few years ago he grabbed Ian Smith's arm, got a straight red.

Then you have a fews weeks ago where Luke Gale looked like he purposely walked into the ref (Thaler again) yet nothing was said or done.

Re: Surrounding the ref : Mon Apr 27, 2015 2:32 pm  

Don't understand why refs allow this abuse
The NRL again lead by example as was in the incident with James Graham and David Klemmer
Both banned for 3 matches for abusive language and crowding the ref
Graham got an extra match for (foul play) mmm bit suspicious
But the NRL like aussies are take no S H one T
Klemmer even got the bin (although there was only 1 minute left)
Is anyone listening at HQ? Hello?