Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Mon Sep 11, 2017 9:44 pm  

Trainman wrote:

I'll do you a deal. Give me the Clubb try and a match winning 6 points and you can have your 2 league points from Friday. Given the choice I'd rather have that bit of luck in a CC final than a super 8's game.

Sure, if you give me the drop out and chalk off the try in the following set when it was 18-10 and we were in total control

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Mon Sep 11, 2017 11:31 pm  

Wigan fans moaning about getting a raw deal from referees is like Stalin moaning over why he got bad press over introducing gulags

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 6:07 am  

Wigg'n wrote:

You lost because you had 12 men? Or because you couldn't close out the game? Or because Sneyd's tackling is poop? Or because Shaul knocked on when you had the chance to win the game again?

More convenient to blame someone else though I guess.

Had we had 13 men, Sneyd may not have had to make that tackle due to one man extra in defence. He certainly wouldn't have been as tired having to defend his line one man down. The short kick off and Shaul knock on wouldn't have mattered.

But you pretend that having a player down in a rugby league match isn't that much of a disadvantage. It just shows you don't really know much about the game.

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 6:11 am  

Trainman wrote:

I'll do you a deal. Give me the Clubb try and a match winning 6 points and you can have your 2 league points from Friday. Given the choice I'd rather have that bit of luck in a CC final than a super 8's game.

Match winning? There was loads of time left. Had Hull needed to chase the game, the strategy would most certainly have been different.

It was a knock on anyways. How many no tries do you need to win?! You already got one for the foot on the dead ball line for your second. You nearly got one at the end for a forward pass. If it wasn't for a lucky bounce at the start of the game, you'd have been nilled

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 9:42 am  

Wellsy13 wrote:

Match winning? There was loads of time left. Had Hull needed to chase the game, the strategy would most certainly have been different.

It was a knock on anyways. How many no tries do you need to win?! You already got one for the foot on the dead ball line for your second. You nearly got one at the end for a forward pass. If it wasn't for a lucky bounce at the start of the game, you'd have been nilled

Pretty sure you can't take Gildart's try away from us now matter how much you might want to

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 4:58 pm  

Wilde 3 wrote:

No charge for Liam Watts. The RFL see sense, though probably down to the social media attention from current/ex players about it being the wrong decision.

Thanks to the referee, we have been reduced to 12 men, in a vitally important game that we lost in the last few minutes, due to an incorrect call. Brilliant.

He was charged and given sending off sufficient. That means it wasn't a wrong decision.

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 5:31 pm  

proper-shaped-balls wrote:

He was charged and given sending off sufficient. That means it wasn't a wrong decision.

He wasn't charged or cautioned.

The RFL wrote:

After Round 5 of the Betfred Super League and Qualifiers Super 8s, the following players have been charged by the Match Review Panel;

Dean Hadley (Wakefield Trinity) - Grade B Dangerous Contact (EGP available)

Josh Walters (Featherstone Rovers) - Grade A Other Contrary Behaviour (EGP available)

Luke Briscoe (Featherstone Rovers) - Grade B Punching (EGP not available)

Louis Anderson (Catalans Dragons) - Grade A Punching (EGP available)



The following players were issued with a Caution by the Match Review Panel;

Keal Carlile (Featherstone Rovers) - Dangerous Contact

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 6:32 pm  

ComeOnYouUll wrote:

He wasn't charged or cautioned.

By saying sending off sufficient the RFL are basically saying that his punishment has already being served Instead of incorrect on field decision, no case to answer.

Re: GAME ON : Hull FC v Wigan Warriors - 20:00:00 : Tue Sep 12, 2017 7:24 pm  

How was Houghton not charged for this? unbelievable. Hull run The RFL!