Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 1:28 pm  

Adam_Harrison9 wrote:

Some simple questions for you to answer:

Did ah van lift Gibson's legs above the horizontal and drive his head in a direction towards the ground?

Is this dangerous contact?

Is this worhty of sin binning?

Is pushing a player off someone who is injured ever penalised?

Can you clearly see what happens in the incident after involving Moore, Ah Van and Heremaia?


Reply to each one separately.

I don't think anyone is being biased. Both the Ellis and Ah Van incidences were at the very least sin bin offences. Both reckless and dangerous contact. It's quite simple if you have a functioning pair of eyes and know the rules of the game. Unfortunately for the referee he only gets one split second look at it and has to deal with everything else happening around him.

I think Wakey fans "went over the top" because it's frustrating when you are not the ones benefiting from the ensuing disciplinary.

Reply to each one separately, who are you my teacher.

I think on the highlights the ref got it right on all those decisions.

Can't speak for the other two sin bins.

Moore was involved in 3 incidents, the hard high tackle looked bad and deserved a red, Heremia reacted twice so deserved to go, Ah Van was a fair sin binning, not worth a red.

Moore is an idiot, always had been and went looking for Ah Van, could have cost you the game, I wouldn't be happy with him if he was a Hull player.

Again well done on recent results, but stop thinking the ref etc are all against you.

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 1:39 pm  

Willzay wrote:

Someone pass Betts a box of tissues - how is this git allowed near the international set up.

ex Wigan Player ?

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 1:41 pm  

A hull fan telling a Wakey fan to stop thinking refs are against them - irony meter gone critical.

All fans are guilty of complaining about the refs, why are you emphasising that only Wakey fans are complaining about the refs? I could go on every other board and find similar comments.

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 3:06 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

:lol: Reply to each one separately, who are you my teacher.

I think on the highlights the ref got it right on all those decisions.

Can't speak for the other two sin bins.

Moore was involved in 3 incidents, the hard high tackle looked bad and deserved a red, Heremia reacted twice so deserved to go, Ah Van was a fair sin binning, not worth a red.

Moore is an idiot, always had been and went looking for Ah Van, could have cost you the game, I wouldn't be happy with him if he was a Hull player.

Again well done on recent results, but stop thinking the ref etc are all against you.

I don't think refs are against us. I think they're dire in general. I wasn't arguing here that refs are against us, I think Cobb got all the decisions right. It was you who was saying that we're biased for saying it should have been a yellow/red. Something you've just admitted in your last post I think the ref got it right on all the incidents.

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 3:46 pm  

Adam_Harrison9 wrote:

I don't think refs are against us. I think they're dire in general. I wasn't arguing here that refs are against us, I think Cobb got all the decisions right. It was you who was saying that we're biased for saying it should have been a yellow/red. Something you've just admitted in your last post I think the ref got it right on all the incidents.

It was a yellow, if you bothered to read the full thread I was responding to the Wakey fan who said Ah Van was a definite red card.

To be fair I've just read Betts comments and worst than any Wakey fan so far.

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 3:55 pm  

In retrospect Cobb did ok with a difficult game last night. I suspect both clubs will be up at Red Hall off the back of last night.

Re: GAME ON : Widnes Vikings v Wakefield Trinity Wildcats - : Sat Apr 30, 2016 3:56 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

It was a yellow, if you bothered to read the full thread I was responding to the Wakey fan who said Ah Van was a definite red card.

To be fair I've just read Betts comments and worst than any Wakey fan so far.

It should probably have been a red let's face it. However, a yellow was better than nothing. It could have broken his neck.