Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sat Oct 18, 2014 1:42 pm  

JEAN CAPDOUZE wrote:

If you don't buy it then you are a goose. This is the weakest Australian team in 50 years. Matthew Scott is not playing and the only specialist prop in the side is Aaron Woods. The Burgess twins and James Graham with the support of Chris Hill will make mincemeat of the Australian pack.

The Kiwis are without Jared Wharea-Hargreaves and Roger Tuivasa-Sheck, both of whom are key first choice players.

If England cannot win this series then they have no hope in the future of international rugby league.

We have better props and that is it.Australia with that team are still superior in the back row,at hooker in the halves,centres and at full back if inglis plays there.we are also away from home.

We are still big underdogs.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 8:56 am  

Likely Kangaroo team/Likely England team

1. Inglis/Tomkins
2. Tupou/Hall
3. Jennings/Watkins
4. Walker/Shenton
5. Johnston/Charnley
6. Cherry Evans/Widdop
7. Cronk/Smith
8. Scott/Graham
9. Smith/Clark
10. Woods/Burgess
11. Hoffman/Ferres
12. Thaiday/Tomkins
13. Bird/O'loughlin
14. Papali/Burgess
15. Parker/Hill
16. Guerra/Farrell
17. Farrah/Hodgson

Outside backs-fairly even, I would just favour Aus due to Inglis

Halfbacks/hooker-Aus

Props-England

Back Row-Aus

We're in with a chance but still big underdogs.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 9:14 am  

I disagree that the outside backs are fairly even - only Hall and Watkins are really anywhere near even, and that's not taking into account Watkins has been in average form this year at best.

Our props are head and shoulders above theirs, but that's it's. Our starting back row will be able to live with theirs for maybe 60 minutes, but they've got massive impact off the bench that we're lacking - I'd guess it will be the same old story where we compete for 60 mins and then they run away with it in the end. That's where Sam Burgess will be sorely missed - he'd have probably done 80 mins in the backrow and would have been the best forward on the park.

I really hope they prove me wrong - I'll be cheering them on all the way and will no doubt feel a lot more optimistic come kick off.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 9:20 am  

As we've seen in many games, the best team 'on paper' doesn't always win.

Australian teams will always have an advantage over English as they are used to playing high intensity games all season and not just for 4/5 games a year. You can take average players and put them together and make them very hard to beat if they are conditioned i playing high intensity, quick, controlled rugby.


This may change over the next few years as more players are involved in the NRL.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 10:53 am  

The mighty Sydney Roosters have announced that prop forward Samuel Moa has withdrawn from the New Zealand Four Nations squad "for family reasons."

This is a big blow for the Kiwis. Moa is a powerful presence in attack and defense. Moa's team mate and fellow prop Jared Wharea-Hargreaves had already made himself unavailable. It gives the England front row clear superiority over their Kiwi equivalents.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 11:03 am  

This 4N tournament ought to be renamed the Coitus Interruptus tournament given the number of withdrawals.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Sun Oct 19, 2014 11:03 pm  

Four Nations tournament kicks off early!

Four Nations tournament kicks off early!

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Mon Oct 20, 2014 1:16 am  

The weakest Aus team in 50 years was the one that narrowly won the Ashes in 2003. The backs then (particularly centres - Craig Wing, Mick De Vere, Phil Bailey) were way worse than the current squad. Despite that causing them a massive loss of point-scoring capability, they still won all three tests.

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Mon Oct 20, 2014 2:06 am  

William Eve wrote: Four Nations tournament kicks off early! ....now now Billy They were just letting off steam

William Eve wrote: Four Nations tournament kicks off early! ....now now Billy They were just letting off steam

Re: 4 Nations Squads : Mon Oct 20, 2014 10:35 pm  

Maybe this is just me but everyone is so negative about 4 nations, and regardless of the outcome of the tournament people on here will just tear England to shreds over it. If we lose, there will be page after page of "same old garbage" and "Mc Banana Out" and if we win people will just say that we were up against weakened opposition and it's not a real win. And god forbit if we get beat by Samoa, regardless of the fact that whilst they may not be players who would be first choice in either Australia or New Zealand's starting line up, it is still a squad of NRL first teamers with a couple of super league players, players who are used to the intensity of the NRL week and week out, they will be no push overs. But I fear if they do win any games, there won't be very many comments of, "well we may now have a side who can compete with big 3 at long last!" it will just be all doom and gloom and comments about what a sorry state the game is in.

As long as all the games are close and competitive and England put a good effort in, I will be happy. As people have mentioned, there probably isn't a better time than now to come home with the trophy and hopefully a competition win will maybe bring some more interest into the sport and more emphasis on the international scene. Here's hoping anyway.