Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Fri Oct 09, 2015 4:58 pm  

mystic eddie wrote:

He does not make in any way because he is not a good coach.

As you well know.

Fancy you being pedantic FA.

If you can't actually write what you mean to say, it's not my fault. It isn't pedantic to be able to count to 2. The 2 criteria were "good player" as well as "good coach" and you clearly said he didn't meet the criteria.

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Fri Oct 09, 2015 9:18 pm  

[quote="Ferocious Aardvark"]Sure. McNamara was a completely useless player, his record speaks for itself, and having coached England to a great performance and agonizingly unlucky last minute defeat to the World Champions, is clearly useless at that too.

Also, you don't need to have been a "good player" to make it as a coach.[/quote



Maurice Bamford anyone ??

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Sat Oct 10, 2015 7:02 am  

Ferocious Aardvark wrote:

If you can't actually write what you mean to say, it's not my fault. It isn't pedantic to be able to count to 2. The 2 criteria were "good player" as well as "good coach" and you clearly said he didn't meet the criteria.

Are you actually that arrogant to think that you can still try to convince people that McNamara was anything but a failure?

Anyway, I will leave it there and hopefully this can now get back on topic.

EDITED - PUMPERS

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 10:20 am  

Apart from the "you deserve everything, you got etc." brigade. The posts are fairly sensible! However what we have missed here is the strategic situation that applied to all the middle 8 clubs, and of course the top eight in SL, Halifax for example stated they weren't interested in getting into SL this year, accordingly they stated the extra £250k would be used to grow their playing base, should they finish above Leigh, which they did. The strategy from the Bulls could have been, we can't be knocked off the 2nd spot and it is important we don't suffer any more injuries for the £m game. The same applied to Wakefield who had the benefit of playing the day after us, so knew what they had or hadn't to do. The SL teams who were out of the top 4 and didn't have a chance of gaining a semi final spot, also gave up the ghost where results didn't matter.
So all in all 10 clubs in the two tiers didn't have anything to play for in the Super and Middle 8s.
And with the so called £m game? Wakefield had home advantage against a weakened Champ side who had the impossible task of playing a team who had played at a more intense level all season. P&R was never going to happen was it? At least Halifax-Leigh and Sheffield perhaps realised it before causing themselves too much additional grief.

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 11:43 am  

mystic eddie wrote:

Are you actually that arrogant to think that you can still try to convince people that McNamara was anything but a failure?

Anyway, I will leave it there and hopefully this can now get back on topic.

I very much doubt you will leave it there, as you have no interest in topics, you just come out with ad hominem and coarse insults, with your regular straw men thrown in. But that is what you enjoy. For my part I will just continue to stick to the subjects.

On McNamara I am neither trying nor wish to "convince" anyone of anything. I just advance my opinion, and where relevant, back it up with facts. Such as McNamara was made, and remains, the England/GB coach, and a good fist he has made of it so far too. Which is presumably why he remains in post. I'm not "trying" to tell you this. It is true. It really annoys you, and that makes it better.

Oh, and you are trying to deflect attention from your faux pas, in accidentally suggesting McNamara was also not a good player. He was. Very good.

[Pumpetypump]

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 11:53 am  

Cassandra wrote:

Maurice Bamford anyone ??

Or indeed the inverse where utterly superb players turn into dreadful coaches. Gary Schofield being a wonderful player, but a god-awful coach, terrible pundit and all round gobshyte of epic proportions. Ellery Hanley a staggering athlete but appeared to combine the strange qualities of incredible arrogance and below average IQ post-retirement.

I'm sure there are many others.

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 12:24 pm  

TBF Maurice Bamford did have quite the best moustache

[Bulliac]

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 1:46 pm  

The skillset is different from playing to coaching and lots of top players don't make the grade as coach.

Compare, Neil Fox, incomparable as a player but gave up coaching almost before his career got started; Peter Fox, very average as a player, but achieved just about every honour in the game as a coach.

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 2:00 pm  

If Peter Fox had been the coach for the MPG then we would have won.

[Bulliac]

Re: Why was promotion and relegation scrapped? : Wed Oct 21, 2015 2:26 pm  

Ah, yes, but he'd have brought back Johnny Wolford at stand off and Jackie [the hand-off] Austin on the wing.....no matter how old they are now,.... how could we have lost with those two in the side?