Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 7:15 am  

I can see Walker winning Super Leagues young player of the year award. Mik Oledski could also be a contender, two positives to come out of the 2018 season.

Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 10:12 am  

Yes walker is fantastic to watch even in a team that has been on the back foot most of the season. Could never understand McDermott even thinking Goulding was in the same bracket

Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 10:55 am  

jensenFF wrote:

Yes walker is fantastic to watch even in a team that has been on the back foot most of the season. Could never understand McDermott even thinking Goulding was in the same bracket

McDermott didn’t, it was just certain fans.

Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 4:28 pm  

jensenFF wrote:

Yes walker is fantastic to watch even in a team that has been on the back foot most of the season. Could never understand McDermott even thinking Goulding was in the same bracket

No one thinks Goulding is in the same bracket as Walker, that's because we don't have a Goulding playing for us.

Once again the Walker fan boys are out as he looks half decent against canon fodder, easy looking good against 12 man Leigh and perhaps the worse super league side since london broncos in 2014. Can't do it against any half decent side, all hype nothing more, be playing at fev or Bradford with lilley in 2 years time.

Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 4:31 pm  

Deary me

Re: Jack Walker : Sun Jul 22, 2018 5:42 pm  

rollin thunder wrote:

No one thinks Goulding is in the same bracket as Walker, that's because we don't have a Goulding playing for us.

Once again the Walker fan boys are out as he looks half decent against canon fodder, easy looking good against 12 man Leigh and perhaps the worse super league side since london broncos in 2014. Can't do it against any half decent side, all hype nothing more, be playing at fev or Bradford with lilley in 2 years time.

Just out of interest did you see,attend or WATCH any of his games last year namely the GF but the others he played in?
He's hit some inconsistency this year but no worse than the team nor Golding.
The kid will be a great FB for us & we can re-visit this in your 2yrs prediction.

Re: Jack Walker : Mon Jul 23, 2018 8:11 am  

RHINO-MARK wrote:

Just out of interest did you see,attend or WATCH any of his games last year namely the GF but the others he played in?
He's hit some inconsistency this year but no worse than the team nor Golding.
The kid will be a great FB for us & we can re-visit this in your 2yrs prediction.

pretty much saw all his games last season and this, i hope you are right and i am right, that would be the best scenario, believe me i would not take pleasure in being a "told you so" much rather he did become a world beater, i just dont see it. But if i am right and he as been over hyped, the mob will soon turn on him. unfortunately people were saying the same things about Sutcliffe 3-4 years ago and others in the past.

Re: Jack Walker : Mon Jul 23, 2018 8:47 am  

rollin thunder wrote:

pretty much saw all his games last season and this, i hope you are right and i am right, that would be the best scenario, believe me i would not take pleasure in being a "told you so" much rather he did become a world beater, i just dont see it. But if i am right and he as been over hyped, the mob will soon turn on him. unfortunately people were saying the same things about Sutcliffe 3-4 years ago and others in the past.

Why does it have to be world beater or nothing? There isn't even people saying that, only you making that assumption. Why can't we just have a damn good player, who is the best at the club in his position, and as the potential to improve further? What is the issue with that?

Re: Jack Walker : Mon Jul 23, 2018 8:48 am  

rollin thunder wrote:

No one thinks Goulding is in the same bracket as Walker, that's because we don't have a Goulding playing for us.

Once again the Walker fan boys are out as he looks half decent against canon fodder, easy looking good against 12 man Leigh and perhaps the worse super league side since london broncos in 2014. Can't do it against any half decent side, all hype nothing more, be playing at fev or Bradford with lilley in 2 years time.

Golding fan boy.

Re: Jack Walker : Mon Jul 23, 2018 9:10 am  

Gotcha wrote:

Why does it have to be world beater or nothing? There isn't even people saying that, only you making that assumption. Why can't we just have a damn good player, who is the best at the club in his position, and as the potential to improve further? What is the issue with that?

but thats what people are making him out to be, thats what this post started out as, people talking about the hype, like i said hope i am wrong, although my comments where slightly tongue in cheek above out playing for Fev, but he is not the golden boy some are making out.