Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 3:16 pm  

Is Achurch a McDermott favourite?

He played well last week so was there any reason to drop him?

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 3:23 pm  

rhinos21 wrote:

Is Achurch a McDermott favourite?

I know, when he didn't even make the 19 man squads at the start of the year and playing for Fev some people were saying it was obviously because he's not a McDermott favourite.

As soon as someone is picked he must be a McDermott favourite, he doesn't get picked it's because he's not in McDermott's favourites group.

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 4:29 pm  

Having watched it back, whilst obviously a poor attempt on Williams by Achurch, both Singleton and Segeyaro get a hand to Williams and produce pretty poor attempts also.

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 5:56 pm  

I think people underestimate William's upper body strength, pace & side-step.
Give him credit for scoring the try not blame Achurch for "letting him".

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 6:29 pm  

Old Feller wrote:

I think people underestimate William's upper body strength, pace & side-step.
Give him credit for scoring the try not blame Achurch for "letting him".

Are you kidding? He didn't side step anything. He went through the 6'7" turnstile like a knife through butter. Williams deserves credit for taking on the defensive line, but as for upper body strength, he was against Achurch not Escare

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sat Jul 16, 2016 6:59 pm  

Achurch looks like Tarzan but plays like Jane

For those ridiculing Kirke
Irrespective of how much cap space was spent on either player, I would much rather have had Kirke in my 17 each week rather than soft cock Achurch
Kirke could be relied upon by all of his coaches to come on, even in a GF cameo role, and do his job well,he would take minimal carries and for very little ground gained,but he would defend the line like his life depended on it

Achurch on the other hand is a soft cock turnstile with the heart the size of a flea

He ought to get his priorities right and spend his life mincing around his gym in his Lycra shorts and Having his legs waxed or even having a spray tan

If you consider what salary Achurch has supposedly been on too,then it's Nathan Picchi all day long for me too i'm afraid,never mind Kirke

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sun Jul 17, 2016 5:16 am  

When people start to talk about a player as being inferior to Ian Kirke you know its that time

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sun Jul 17, 2016 11:29 am  

He was also crumpled 1 on1 by Williams before he lost the ball on our 10m zone as wel.
I've said since "Escaregate" he isnt good enough hopefully friday aslo puts paid to those who think he'd be worth a new deal.

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sun Jul 17, 2016 2:22 pm  

The Chin's Back wrote:

Achurch looks like Tarzan but plays like Jane

For those ridiculing Kirke
Irrespective of how much cap space was spent on either player, I would much rather have had Kirke in my 17 each week rather than soft cock Achurch
Kirke could be relied upon by all of his coaches to come on, even in a GF cameo role, and do his job well,he would take minimal carries and for very little ground gained,but he would defend the line like his life depended on it

Achurch on the other hand is a soft cock turnstile with the heart the size of a flea

He ought to get his priorities right and spend his life mincing around his gym in his Lycra shorts and Having his legs waxed or even having a spray tan

If you consider what salary Achurch has supposedly been on too,then it's Nathan Picchi all day long for me too i'm afraid,never mind Kirke

I always thought Nathan Picchi had a storming 20 mins before dislocating his shoulder in his debut and ending his Leeds career.Your not comparing eggs with eggs.

Re: Isn't Achurch brilliant? : Sun Jul 17, 2016 6:15 pm  

Dwayne Dibley wrote:

I always thought Nathan Picchi had a storming 20 mins before dislocating his shoulder in his debut and ending his Leeds career.Your not comparing eggs with eggs.

We both agree on Pichii having a great cameo appearance for the Rhinos but he is often referred to as one of the lesser talented players that played for our club during a troubled season and was only on peanuts probably and found his RL level whilst playing for Rochdale

I was using Pichii as a derisory comparison to illustrate my utter contempt towards Achurchs' career at the Rhinos and the supposedly big money contract he was paid to tempt him over from Penrith

Kirke was worth every penny paid to him IMO in a salary capped sport and did a bloody good cameo job each game he played for us